Sunday, July 22, 2012

Lineas to Cross in a Lifetime

   Ann Jaramillo's novel, La Linea, is a fictional story based on real events.  Ann met her husband Luis in the 1970's, where his family welcomed her with open arms.  It was here that Ann developed a sense of understanding when she learns about the difficulties and struggles that many have faced to cross the border line.  The afterwards states, "We didn't come to the United States.  The United States came to us."  This sentence reflects on how many times this country has turned a family around, and provided hope to those with none.
   La Linea is a story of struggle and hope for a young fifteen year old boy who longs to be reunited with his mom and dad in California.  What was a year of promise turned into seven, and on his birthday, the time had come.  San Jacnito did not offer stability of survival; the corn had dried up and families had left behind any hopes and dreams of making adequate income.
  Before he could leave, the reader learns various vocabulary terms, such as 'coyote'.  Through context clues, students quickly learn this is a man to help one travel across the desert safely.  Mata gente is the train that travels north, and pueblitos are communities in which residents help those migrants seeking a better life in the north.
   To me, it was an eye-opener reading this book.  Since I was little, I have heard the stereotypes of Mexicans crossing the border, thinking it is an easy task, which is why so many are here in this country.   Though I have argued the point they are here to better themselves and their children, others still have a distaste for their existence.  Reading about the children riding the mata gente was very frightening; Javi, the adopted companion on Miguel's journey, was concerned for gangs capturing and molesting these children.  It makes you also think about the amount of parents who have left their children behind to provide money and send back to a housekeeper.  How awful it must be to be separated and live across "la Linea".
    One of the most significant lines in this novel to me was "I didn't understand that there are thousands of lineas to cross in a life.  Sometimes you see the border and you walk right across, eyes wide open.  You know you will change.  You know everything will be different.  Other times, you don;t know you've crossed a border until you reach the other side.  Until you turn, and look back at la linea, surprised" (125).    This is a perfect open-ended response to get the students reflecting on their own lines they have crossed in their life.  How many times have we crossed decisions without looking back?
  Miguel knew he wouldn't look back.  The United States was where he longed to be; though throughout the story,  the reader felt dis-contempt for his father.  How could he deny Don Clemente the opprtunity to send his son earlier?  It wasn't until Miguel was older, "It took me years to accept that Papa did what he did out of love, not pride" (121).  Yet, his twin siblings will never know the struggle of la linea.  Something he will carry with him.
    Overall, this book teaches children a lot about struggle for Mexican-Americans.  Miguel and his younger sister, Elena, had to make many life-altering decisions.  If it had not been for certain moments, people, and circumstances, they may not have made it, just as the mom and baby left in the sand.


    In reference to the text, Young Adult Literature in the Classroom, "the eleven million immigrants age 10 or over who came to the United States during the 1990s accounted for more than one third of the nation's population growth" (45).   This, to me, tells the struggle of so many children and so many people to better their lives.   Students need to be exposed to diverse culture and diverse literature for this specific reason: ten million is all over our country, including our own towns.  As the text states, "Literature provides one important resource for all students to learn about themselves and others" (47).   I like the teacher idea on page 60, which lists character analysis vocabulary to help students identify dynamic words to describe the characters.  With this list, students can identify web cards to describe Javi, Elena, Miguel, Mama, Papa, and even Abuelita.  It would allow students to examine how dynamic they were to the main character, and how they worked together.  Overall, this novel has a lot of insight to offer young minds about the biases in our country.  I feel eighth graders could use a novel like this to break stereotypes, and to understand the struggle behind the travel.  Because even when they reach their destination, there are always more "la lineas" to cross.

3 comments:

  1. The "Border Patrol" police clip provided by NPR really makes one reflect on the American safety and migrant safety. The stories detailed the verbal, physical, and sexual abuse that migrants experienced when captured by the Border police.
    One American citizen, a woman traveling with her daughter, videotaped the verbal abuse and harassment experienced going through the patrol.
    only 1 in 7 received proper medical care. After traveling days in the desert, as reading Miguel's story, these men have been punished. One man discusses how he was crammed in a room with 120 people, where the occupancy should be no more than 48.
    Are the border patrol agents truly protecting our boundary lines? Are they forgetting they are human beings and not animals?
    The abuse experienced should not be tolerated, or hidden from view.
    It makes one reflect on what foundations are being instilled in these men and women.
    For example the officer who decided to kick all of the water bottles over where bodies have been found in the desert. Pouring the water on the ground. These issues need to be addressed.

    Doesn't this connect back to our conversation with 'heroes' of power? These border patrol police officers- do they really represent our country?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I believe that the combination of the novel La Linea, along with the video about the immigration agents should prompt a very in-depth discussion about the treatment of "others." I chose this book not because I wished to encourage illegal immigration, but rather because I was looking for a story that would help our students to understand the risks people will take in order to make a "better life" for themselves, to find/reunite with loved ones or to gain economic opportunity. I believe that our students have no idea the suffering that many people go through, the years of separation from family, in order to gain entry into this country. I believe that a discussion of the reasons for leaving one's country needs to be introduced here. What are these people experiencing back home? Are they really taking the jobs of Americans when they come here? How should they be treated when they come to this country..............even though they will be sent back? Why are they not treated humanely?

    I like the analogy that you draw................we cross many la lineas in our lifetime. Let's talk about those crossings!!!!! Dr. Ries

    ReplyDelete
  3. The part you reference about crossing thousands of lines...I love the idea about using it for an open-ended response. I also keep thinking about reading that segment to 8th graders about to graduate middle school. If they have to write graduation speeches, that could be poignant theme for them to think about.

    ReplyDelete